Daniel W. Vomhof III

Presentation Materials for

SATAI October 2026

 

NHTSA Crash Test Data Problems and Common Misconceptions

This presentation shows a "Special Case" method to calculate a "FLOOR" speed in a motorcycle collision using Vehicle Crush, Wheelbase "Reduction", and the Crush Factor values as published in Expert AutoStats.

Download Motorcycle FLOOR Speed from Crush Presentation - 1 Slide per page

This presentation shows a "Special Case" method to calculate speed from crush in "Narrow Object" (i.e. - POLE) crashes using the Crush Factor values as published in Expert AutoStats.

Download Use of Crush Factor in "Narrow Object"  Presentation - 1 Slide per page

Stiffness Calculations for Pole Impacts based on NHTSA Crash Test Database
(Supplemental Data)

Download Pole Data - Frontal Impact - "A" less than 700 - Crush less than 30 inches - MAX Crush

Download Pole Data - Side Impact - "A" less than 700 - "B" less than 700 - Crush less than 30 inches - MAX Crush

Download Pole Data - Frontal Impact - "A" less than 700 - AVG Crush

Download Pole Data - Side Impact - "A" less than 700 - "B" less than 700 - AVG Crush

This presentation deals with some common, but misunderstood, problems within the NHTSA Crash Test data.

Download Crash Test Data and Common Misconceptions Presentation - 1 Slide per page

CASE 1 - This case problem out of Australia was the instigation of the NHTSA Problems presentation and illustrates how some of the misconceptions and problems can lead to an error in calculating speeds in the subject collision.

Download Case Data Illustration - CASE 1 - 1 Slide per page

CASE 2 - This case problem out of Florida illustrates that the crash investigator/reconstructionist cannot rely upon having EDR/CDR information available, even when the vehicles are supported vehicles.  It also illustrates some basic calculations, including crush from photographs, and how they can be used to establish a speed when nothing else is available. This is also the first illustration of "Do a Professional Job"

Download Case Data Illustration - CASE 2 - 1 Slide per page

CASE 3 - This case example out of California illustrates that the crash investigator/reconstructionist cannot rely upon having EDR/CDR information available, even when the vehicles are supported vehicles.  It also illustrates some basic calculations, including crush from photographs, and how they can be used to establish a speed when nothing else is available. Finally this touches on Video Analysis issues as well as "Professional vs Check Box" and what it can do to a case.

Download Case Data Illustration - CASE 3 - 1 Slide per page

This "Case Example" is actually a Crash Test Study from the 2026 IPTM Symposium. It Illustrates some "scanning" tools, accuracy of scans, and the use of Force Balance to calculate speeds from crush.

Download Case Data Illustration - IPTM 2026 Crash Test 2 - 1 Slide per page

CASE 1 to CASE 3 Supplemental Material Attachments Download Case Data Supplemental Material

Selected video from the 2023 Pennsylvania State Patrol conference that help to illustrate some of the issues and problems discussed in the first part of the presentation.
(Supplemental Video Data)

Videos from the 2023 PSP conference that help to illustrate the problems referenced in the first part of the presentation.

2023 Pennsylvania State Police Conference - Speed Calculation Spreadsheet
(Supplemental Data)

2023 PSP Excel Speed Calculation Spreadsheet

Video Presented by the District Attorney in Case Example 3
(Supplemental Video Data)

 

 

SCARS 2025 Video - Illustrates Impact location vs spin - Used as part of Case Exampl 3
(Supplemental Video Data)

Crash Test 1 - 6oclock camera

Crash Test 1 - 7oclock camera

 Crash Test 1 - combined video

 Crash Test 2 - 6oclock camera

 Crash Test 2 - 7oclock camera

Crash Test 2 - combined video

Case 3 Speed Calculation Spreadsheet Output
(Supplemental Data)

Case 3 Speed Calculation Spreadsheet Output

Speed Survey material. This has SPECIFIC applicability to California
(Supplemental Data)

Caltrans Speed Survey Manual
2018 Speed Survey
2021 Speed Survey

 

DOWNLOAD ALL OF THE ABOVE PRESENTATION MATERIAL FROM DROPBOX

 

 

 

Web site References

Cloud Compare

https://www.danielgm.net/cc/release/index.html

 

Precision vs Accuarcy

The Science of Measurement: Accuracy vs. Precision

 

Practices of Science: Precision vs. Accuracy

 

What Is the Difference Between Accuracy and Precision?
Accuracy is close to a known value; precision measures repeatability

 

What is the meaning of accuracy and precision in Science?

 

 

 

Return to
4N6XPRT Systems Conference Material and Presentations Page